How Nichiren’s disciples were influenced by the Gohonzon they received and the moji-mandala versus the tridimensional honzon.
Summary
Although Nichiren bestowed a large calligraphic mandala to each of his senior and mid-tier disciples in different phases of his predication, it is a fact that he kept a statue of Śakyamuni for his whole life. Next to a large mandala, now preserved at Josaizan Sogen-ji in Mobara, the effigy was enshrined at his base in Minobu as it is customary for temples to have a main hall (hondo) and an “image hall” dedicated to its main Buddha. The rudimental Kuon-ji however could not afford the luxury of several buildings, it is hence not completely clear which was the main honzon adopted at the time. For sure, many lay believers made a perilous pilgrimage to the site in order to receive their calligraphic mandala.
This paper analyzes how different disciples perceived the transmission from Nichiren, basing their own schools on the mandala they received and the particular period it was inscribed for them. Some cases are fairly obvious, as Izumi ajari Nippo produced mandalas with the same side inscriptions that Nichiren placed on the Gohonzon he received. Nippo was also in contact with the lay believers that received the largest mandala ever produced by Nichiren made of 28 sheets, which also bears the same floating quotations of the Lotus Sūtra. The cases of Nichiro and Nikko are more nuanced for a number of reasons.
It seems evident however, that senior disciples received their Gohonzon already in the Bun’ei era (1264~1275), while the others either in the Kenji (1275~1277) or mostly in the Kōan period (1278~). After Nichiren passed away, his successors would adopt either the calligraphic mandala or enshrine various formats of statue groupings, at times fiercely debating about which type of honzon shall be adopted in the Nichiren sangha.
The various honzon formats are described and analyzed within a broader non-sectarian context while trying to harmonize all the different views. It can be asserted that Nichiren considered the Lotus teaching as “word” of the Eternal Buddha that defines the moment in which humanity became self-conscious and detached from the realm of beasts. He evidently knew that the scripture is the result of several translators, compilers, thinkers and philosophers who made their additions to the ultimate Lotus script. However he considered the canonical text as final and perfect, almost like a chorus that intones about enlightenment in magnificent harmony.
References to the series “The Mandala in Nichiren Buddhism” (vol. 1~3) are abbreviated as MNB, the canon of Nichiren’s writings Showa Teihon Nichiren Shonin Ibun as STN and “Writings of Nichiren Daishōnin” as WND.
Two main points are to be considered. The first is how Nichiren’s successors were visually influenced by the mandalas they received, which is a matter pertaining to both graphic perception and the relative skills of image rendering (symbolic and calligraphic). The second and perhaps main point is their doctrinal understanding of the honzon to be propagated for the mappo era.
